Wednesday, August 22, 2012


Time Machine- Utility Player


Dave Hansen (00) – The only 10 utility player I know of from the original 2 sets. In 1999 he had 147 PA in 102 games. 1B/3B+0 really means pinch hitter if you play for the NL. With Beltre playing 152 games at third and Karros playing 151 games at 1B I think they were generous with both.  He played a total of 123.2 innings of defense (less than 14 games). His 2 home runs, 1 triple and 8 doubles that year yielded him 10, speed C, 20 HR, 18-19 2B. I do not see much use for him except that he is a cheap 290 points.


Ryan Klesko (00) – This is likely the best player or at least season to be represented by an original Showdown card. He played 1B for 75 games and LF for 53 games. He had 446 PA, so we are not talking about a pinch hitter. This is a full time starter at 2 positions. He had 21 homers, 2 triples and 28 doubles that season. His +0 fielding for both LF/RF and 1B makes him look like he should be a speed C or B- now. That is not the case he steal 23 bases each of the next 2 years. He was a 9, 18-20 HR, 15-17 2B speed B. His 410 point card was good. Hard to justify him though in years when LF/RF and 1B were so deep.

Denny Hocking (01) – Denny may have been one of the perfect pictures of the Twins of this era. He was not powerful, He was not fast but he was versatile and productive. Hocking had 4 homers, 4 triples and 24 doubles in 433 PA. He also played 10 games or more at 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, LF, RF and CF. He also found time to DH twice that year. The guy had a good enough bat to stay in the line-up but a humble enough attitude to play where he was told. He was a 9, 20 3B, 18-19 2B, 17 1B+ Speed B. CF/2B+2, LF/RF+1. Lots of uses for a guy like this for 260 points.

Phil Nevin (00) – Nevin was one of the great combo players in Showdown. He played 3B for +3 which is perfect and C+5 which is serviceable. Very few utility players play catcher as well. The new cards have a few more C/1B combos. The next 7 seasons after this was made Nevin would catch 4 more games. He was a power 8, 17-20 HR, 14-16 2B which put him right on par with Ripkin and Piazza as power 8’s at their position. He outfielded both for 350 points he was also cheaper than both.

Brant Brown (00P) – I do love freak low charts and this is as good of a position as any to spot light one. Brown is a 5, 15-20 HR, 14 3B, 10-13 2B for 160 points. Brown played 1B+0 and LF/RF+1. This isn’t even the best Brant Brown cards ever made but that is beside the point. He struck out near a third of the times he batted in 1999. He had 16 homers, 3 triples, 20 doubles. He played mostly OF while playing some 1B. It appears he played DH whenever the opportunity presented itself. One of the great bench intimidation players in the game. 



5 comments:

  1. Richie Sexson (00) - This card is probably the best card to have late in a game with the 'Clutch Performance' strategy card. OB 6, 14-20 HR, 12-13 triple, 11 double. The 290 pts puts him higher than almost any reliever, so getting the advantage means a 50% chance of an extra base hit. Perfect for when you need to pinch hit for Einar Diaz.

    ReplyDelete
  2. For a long time Hansen was in the file at position PH ... not a typo ... we eventually decided it wasn't worth adding that complexity for 1 or 2 guys per year

    ReplyDelete
  3. In 2001 Butch Huskey was made a DH despite being on the NL Rockies. Some guys stats there just is no winning with. Huskey has a similar break down of stats and positions. On the eye test he looked a lot more like a DH than Hansen. We always have a spirited debate on what to do with certain players. How many games should make you qualify. and what qualifies someone as a DH (which we point out as purely a PH). The short coming of our system is limiting a great player like Adam Dunn this year to DH makes him so much less useful to the league. Making him a 1B+0 is 1 generous to his defense and 2 an insult to a great Showdown player like Konerko. Life would be nice if every team had 8 guys who played 162 games at 1 position. Gotta love what the stats say about real players though

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dunn has 41 games at first so far, I don't see why you wouldn't just list him there. If it feels like breaking your rules, double down by giving him negative fielding.

    I don't see why Huskey wouldn't have been at least an OF that year, either, given his combined numbers. Seems like someone was just looking at his MIN totals. I don't particularly remember working on the card, but you know, it's just Butch Huskey.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dunn more then qualifies. We traditionally use 10 games as some what of a bench mark. All of his outs will be strike outs and he walks an un-godly amount times. In 09 and 10 (and other years we didn't make) he was good at 2 things. 1: getting on base, 2: hitting home runs. In 2012 he only has 1 of those things going for him. So being slow, striking out and walking are plenty enough penalties that I don't mind giving him 1B. There are too few HR's in the league not to. I read an article a month ago that said we are on pace for 900 less homers then 10 years ago (the old cards). The game has changed.

      In regards to Butch Huskey I am just always a fan of the odd quirks of both baseball and Showdown. A NL player as a DH is just funny to see. We made Giambi a DH for the Rockies too the last few years. there is definitely a philosophical difference between how we made DH's compared to the originals. We treat DH's more like half time players and point them so. In NL only leagues they are the best PH's for the price. In AL leagues they are by far the best DH's for the price (way over powered to be honest, people may consider banning them) Luckily we have a little over a month till the hard decisions have to be made about them for 2012 class

      Delete