MLB Showdown: Custom Cards
Here is
the second part of one of our series on 10 cards that one of our fans had
created. It is obvious that he wanted to make cards for 10 of the greatest
seasons every and here is the list with some cards many of you have been
looking forward to.
Barry Bonds 04- Maybe the most impressive statistical
seasons I have ever been able to witness. Barry Bonds got on base roughly an
extra half as many times as the league leader most years. I scoffed at the 16
Bonds that Wizards of the Coast made under their new play style when it came
out. A .608 OBP with 45 homers is beyond impressive. The problem with this card
is how does he create runs? He is slow and he walks up to a 15. He is not going
to single people in. You can’t steal in in front of him or people will
intentionally walk him or they will pitch to him and he will walk. For 900
points I think he hurts the line-up more than he helps it. Easy for me to say
until I face a team with him in the line up.
Babe Ruth 1916- Believe it or not Babe Ruth just joined a
list with Rick Ankiel. They are now the only two players in MLB Showdown that
have both a pitcher and batter card. Ruth is going to have a better version of
both. That is no disrespect to Ankiel he was the pioneer. Ruth is an
interesting pitcher from a different era. In 1916 people pitcher more innings
giving the Bambino an 8 IP. Also he gave up less homers than most people now
with a lowish ERA. He also didn’t strike nearly as many people out per 9
innings. That yields an interesting and I think winnable distribution on his
chart. I would never take him over the 1927 batting card but still a great card.
Nolan Ryan 1973- As the only man who ever pitched to Roger
Maris, Sammy Sosa, Barry Bonds and Mark McGwire, Ryan actual may be more of a
legend than those four 60+ homer hitters. Many of our dads idolized Ryan the
way many of us idolize Michael Jordan from this generation. He played the game
the way our fathers wanted to play it. No none sense, here it is try and hit this.
He would never win a Cy Young. Hopefully this will be one of many great cards
of his. As you would expect Ryan would have a large K to match all the other
all-time greats. He also gives up very little damage on his own terms.
Surrendering more walks than anything else. For 8 IP he could really punish
people with a good catcher. With his big K and large walk the catcher is more
of a luxury. He can get himself out of trouble. I think he may stack up well
against any not named Pedro Martinez.
Dennis Eckersley 1990- No great list of players is complete
without a Billy Wagner knock off card. Eck would sport a 0.61 ERA in 1990 while
recording 48 saves. He is the first of hopefully many 1990 A’s players to be
created. Maybe the most impressive will be Eckersley which is hard to believe
against names like Henderson, McGwire and Canseco. He gives up singles with 19-20.
He has a 1-9 none advancing out. He can be stretched. He is as good as you will
do for a closer and he is right on par points wise with Wagner.
Pete Rose 1968- No lack of controversy on this list. Tough
to find a stand out year for Rose. This was as good as any I suppose. He may be
one of the best number 2 hitters to ever be created for Showdown. For 320
points he can single in a great lead-off hitter like FP Santangelo 00 or Brett
Gardner 2010. I was unaware that he played specifically outfield for a few
years of his career until I looked up the stats. This does hurt a tad as he
would be more useful on the infield and saving the outfield for power. Still a
great player with a great and this time usable card.
For information on how to attain your own set and create your own custom cards e-mail Redsoxman2011@gmail.com
Great selection of cards with a variety of different uses! I was hoping someone would ask you to make a Nolan Ryan card and boy, he did not disappoint. As for Bonds, I see both sides of the coin. 900 points is a lot to swallow. On the other hand, if you protect him with a McGwire or, even cheaper, the 2000 Jeffrey Hammonds, you might negate the problem of his speed since players like that would bomb him to home plate. Regardless, you are building your lineup around Barry if that's the case and you are probably going to want a good pitching staff to go along with him.
ReplyDeleteSame rules: Mark McGwire 1999: 10 OB: 16-20 HR. 3 control is (.35)*(.25)=8.75 % homer. Had he been a 15-20 HR he would have had a 10.5% homer closer to his actual 9.83% (65 HR in 661 PA). Elite power hitters as a whole are going end up in tiers more than anything else. I agree there is room for interpretation. 19-20 HR for a 13 we put on the same tier as a 12: 18-20, 11: 17-20, 10: 16-20, 9: 15-20, 8: 14-20. Mark Mcgwire hit 65 homers in 1999 and got a 10: 16-20 HR, Sosa hit 63 in 1999 and got an 8: 14-20. It is tough for me to put him above those elite players. Many of us would agree that if you play raw the game ends up being a hair less offensive than most normal games. However the spread between the good and bad players looks a lot more normal. However when you add strategy cards it seems the game plays a hair more offensive than regular baseball (depending on rules) and the superstars drastically outperform weaker players. We attempt to weigh as many factors as we can when we make these cards.
ReplyDeleteThe factors here how did this Bonds rank amongst all-time greats in terms of OBP? That is pretty easy. Best season ever in terms of getting on base. We (arbitrarily I admit) decided .500 OBP would be 12 OB and .600 OBP would be 13 OB. There is room for debate there. I do believe those are serviceable enough bench marks for determine all-time greatness.
Where does he rank amongst the all-time great home run seasons? 45 homers raw is really good but not those elite McGwire, Sosa and Ruth 27 seasons we have seen. We did decide to place him in that tier however due to the incredible amount of homers he hit in only 373 Abs. He had 27 doubles and triples so we had to play around with it to make a card that worked. We could have done a 20 HR- 18-19 2B. I don’t remember that season that way. We could have done a 18-20 HR no 2B. I remember the season more that way but sadly the stats do not. We made our decision to put him with the McGwire 00, Sosa 00, Bautista 10 power class.
In short recap. There are many variables in play when constructing cards. One very important one that we take seriously is how does this player fit with every other legal card in the Showdown world. Also most elite batters project out to have slightly worse numbers but are still notably better than players worse than them. The spread is probably accurate as the stats may not be perfect. I hope th. is answer your question